Opinion: does Michael Gove know something we don’t?
It would seem that successive Tory government’s have waged an ongoing and progressively more vicious war on buy-to-let landlords, but this latest layer of legislation goes much further.
Yes, this latest iteration, and one that’s before Parliament right now, is the Renter’s Reform Bill which will effectively throws out the 35-year old concept of the “Shorthold Tenancy”, introduced by the Conservative’s Thatcher Government back in 1988.
The Shorthold Tenancy transformed private residential letting in the UK. It removed what was then a much diminished rental market, one that was hamstrung by rent controls and lifelong security of tenure. Landlords had abandoned renting in their droves, and those that hadn’t just allowed their properties to decay. That’s because the return on their investment didn’t justify throwing good money after bad, sinking more money into what had become a “white elephant” investment.
The Shorthold Tenancy removed the risk: it revolutionised the market and put a rocket under it. Landlords could (1) charge a market rent and keep it in-line with the market over time, and (2) they could get their property back, guaranteed. They could remove a bad tenant, albeit with a 6 month delay, using the relatively easy and sure method of the Section 21 process.
Revenge evictions
Enter the Michael Gove’s Renter’s Reform Bill, a Bill which he thinks will improve the tenant’s lot, give them security of tenure and prevent the so called revenge eviction, one that is prompted by landlords receiving complaints from their tenants.
Anyone who understands the lettings industry knows that this type of revenge eviction is a minority event, less that 1 or 2 per cent of evictions are for this reason. Responsible landlords use the Section 21 process very sparingly because they want to keep good tenants. By far the majority of Section 21 evictions are for rent arrears, followed by anti-social behaviour.
Landlords on the whole do not evict good tenants. Tenants who pay their rent on time and look after the property. That’s all landlords are after, and they will go through hell and high water to keep these tenants in their property.
Unfortunately, the so called revenge eviction hits the headlines: the housing charities have used the power of the media to scare the living daylights out of the Government into its abolition, promised now for over four years. There are far more tenants than there are landlords, and the general public will always favour the welfare of tenants over them. At the end of the day it’s a matter of votes.
The reforms in this new Bill threaten to worsen an already serious housing crisis where renters can’t find the homes they need at reasonable prices. It threatens to kill-off the private investor, the final nail in buy-to-let’s coffin.
Tory MP’s concerns
It’s not just landlords who are concerned. Even Tory MPs fear that is will lead to an even more serious housing crisis, forcing more landlords to sell up and more tenants unable to find accommodation they can afford.
The Daily Telegraph reports that “there are growing concerns in the Conservative party that the Government has gone too far in its war on landlords and second homeowners. The renters’ reform bill, due to go before Parliament this week, will abolish ‘no-fault’ evictions and introduce rolling tenancies. It will also prevent landlords from turning away tenants with pets or those on benefits.”
As concerns mount over the Bill more and more landlords who are aware of the coming changes are voting with their feet, they are leaving the industry in anticipation of what’s to come and while they can still get their properties back at will. This Bill really does threaten a mass buy-to-let exodus
The Bill will introduce what will be the biggest change in private renting since 1988 and it’s a very radical one too, swinging the industry clock back towards the rigid controls of the Rent Act (Regulated Tenancy) period that existed before that date.
As rents reach the £1,000 per calendar month level outside of London for the first time, tenants are already facing surging costs, while landlords, in turn, squeezed by successive tax increases, are being hit with rapidly rising mortgage rates. Not only are profit margins tight, in some cases they are non-existent, and the ever increasing regulations make life far harder for the average buy-to-let landlord.
The opposition’s plans
Meanwhile Labour’s shadow housing secretary Lisa Nandy (levelling up) wants these reforms to be implemented as soon as possible and she promises that a labour government would go even further with its own reforms of the private rented sector. This will include longer notice periods, giving tenants freedom to make alterations to the property, a harsher homes standard and it probably means some form of rent control.
Conservative MP Craig Mackinlay, South Thanet in Kent, told The Daily Telegraph:
“The reality is, landlords will abandon the market and we will have a very serious housing crisis on our hands. I’m worried about landlords leaving the market, I really am. There’s a huge amount of disquiet about this. From colleagues I’m talking to, they’re not happy. We have seen too much of a war against landlords.”
Another Conservative, Marco Longhi, Tory MP for Dudley North, told The Telegraph, the renters’ reform bill was “like wielding a hammer to crack a nutshell. It’s a disaster. You will see huge swathes of landlords leave the market, and this has been happening for several months already.
“The Government doesn’t realise how much it depends on private sector landlords. These properties landlords are now selling aren’t even affordable for the majority of renters, so where are these people going to go? We should be building cities twice the size of Sheffield to keep up with net migration.”
The Government’s War on Landlords 1 – George Osborne fired the first round with his tax hikes, changing the way rental income was taxed so that not only were landlords nudged into higher rate tax bands, there was a three per cent surcharge on stamp duty and the wear and tear depreciation allowance was abolished. 2 – Increasing rules and regulations piled on the pressure for landlords, to the point that one missed service of a notice or a vital safety check or risk assessment in a series of increasing complexity when setting up a tenancy meant that landlords were unable to use the Section 21 eviction process. It now takes a very diligent landlord or agent to get everything into place. 3 – Energy efficiency targets and net zero – the MEES regulations mean that some landlords will need to invest considerable sums of money to bring their properties up to future emissions standards, especially as the bulk of rental property are of the older type of construction which are inherently inefficient. 4 – The Right to rent checks were the burden of checking tenants and refusing those without the correct immigration status was placed on landlords. 5 – Restrictions on the amount of fees and deposits landlords can take, were introduced. 6 – Now landlords are faced with the prospect of a Renter’s Reform Bill that will end Section 21, end fixed-term tenancies, it will prevent landlords resisting tenants with pets or those claiming benefits and impose a higher standard of safety – the Decent Homes Standard. |
Section 8 – an adversarial system
By removing Section 21 and imposing an indefinite length tenancy a landlord with a bad tenant will be at the mercy of a convoluted and adversarial Section 8 process, a system where the landlord will have to convince a judge of the necessity to evict a recalcitrant tenant.
What will make this even worse is that no extra resources are planned for a court system that has been slimmed down and is already overloaded – the way things stand it could be 12 months before a landlord can get a tenant who is not paying any rent, into court.
The fact that additional mandatory grounds for eviction are being added to the Section 8 legislation is nether here nor there, if you cannot get your bad tenant into court, you are stuck with them.
It will work against tenants in the end…
The upshot will be that landlords will have to be far more careful and selective when signing up new and untested tenants. They will need to prove they are able to pay the rent, they will probably be required top pass a stringent credit assessment and provide a guarantor. Fortunately, landlords will still be in a position to reject applicants who cannot show they can afford to pay the rent.
The end result as I see it, is that far from making the system fairer for tenants it will work against them. Rent prices will go sky high, there will be such a shortage of rental accommodation that thousand of tenants will be priced out of the market, and even when they can afford it competition for rentals will be intense.
Student landlords
Student landlords are particularly concerned about the prospect of indefinite tenancies as they rely on their student houses being vacated in time for the following influx of students for the start of a new academic year. Unless, this rule is changed for student lettings during the passage of the Bill it will create chaos for student landlords.
The Government is committed
Despite all the arguments landlords can make against these radical changes, a Government spokesman for the Department for Levelling up, Housing and Communities, the Government told The Telegraph it is “absolutely committed to delivering a fairer deal for renters.
“We will bring forward legislation very shortly, which will include a ban on ‘no fault’ evictions, so that all tenants have greater security in their homes and are empowered to challenge poor conditions.
“We are also introducing a Decent Homes Standard for the Private Rented Sector for the first time ever which will make sure privately rented homes are safe and decent,” the Government spokesman said.
We landlords know that the vast majority are responsible landlords are doing a great job, one that most private tenants appreciate. It’s a much smaller minority of landlords that this new legislation is aimed at, but in doing so it affects everyone.
More complaints
The irony is that most landlords are doing a far better job that local government and social housing landlords, despite the Decent House Standard which applies to them right now. As MP, Mr Mackinlay told The Daily Telegraph:
“I receive infinitely more complaints about social housing from renters than I do about private landlords
“Firms don’t do repairs, so problems are hanging around for months if not years. No one responds. If you think these institutions are the panacea for the rental sector, you’re sorely misguided.
“Good landlords are far more responsive. You wouldn’t have a hope in hell of getting something sorted in a few days in social housing, like you would with a landlord.”
View Full Article: Opinion: does Michael Gove know something we don’t?
How HMRC Might Target Hybrid LLP Compliance Checks
The likeliness of HMRC opening “Compliance Checks” into the accounting of Hybrid LLP’s operated by property rental business owners is now at an all-time high.
HMRC could simply target all LLP’s registered at the office addresses of Accountants known to have filed tax returns incorrectly for other their clients.
View Full Article: How HMRC Might Target Hybrid LLP Compliance Checks
Labour to ‘go further than Tories’ with harsher Decent Homes Standard
Labour has promised to ramp up the pressure on private landlords by introducing a legally binding ‘Decent Homes Standard 2’.
Its latest draft policy programme – a provisional blueprint likely to shape the next general election manifesto – includes a proposal to take the government’s planned Decent Homes Standard further, although Labour’s vision is light on detail.
Expected as part of the imminent Renters’ Reform Bill, the Decent Homes Standard would ensure PRS properties are free from serious health and safety hazards.
Landlords would also be expected to keep homes in a good state of repair, so renters have clean, appropriate and useable facilities.
Fundamentally
Labour’s policy programme reiterates its plan to fundamentally reform the private rented sector, giving tenants greater security through a powerful new renters’ charter, which will include longer-term tenancies as standard, the right to reasonable alterations, ending Section 21 ‘no fault’ evictions and introducing a national register of landlords.
The party would also consult on how best to ensure tenancies are affordable and the effective implementation of no-fault evictions.
Other draft Labour policies include a promise to upgrade every home that needs it to EPC standard C within a decade by installing energy-saving measures such as loft insulation in locally delivered programmes, by giving local authorities the power and resources.
It has also set the target of a 70% homeownership rate by helping first-time buyers onto the housing ladder with a new, comprehensive mortgage guarantee scheme as well as bringing the leasehold system to an end.
Raising stamp duty paid by foreign individuals, trusts and companies when they buy UK residential property is another proposal.
Read more about the Decent Homes Standard.
View Full Article: Labour to ‘go further than Tories’ with harsher Decent Homes Standard
EXTRA red tape, scams and repairs drive more landlords to use agencies
Almost two thirds (63%) of private landlords who manage their own properties are tired of sorting out repairs and dealing with red tape and considering using a letting agency or property manager instead.
A Uswitch poll of 2,000 landlords found that the most common reason they might decide to pay an agent was to take a break from dealing with repairs (31%) followed by avoiding the hassle of finding tenants (30%) and avoiding legal responsibilities (30%).
More than a quarter (27%) would switch to a letting agency to avoid scams and fraud.
The comparison site believes that as soaring interest rates force mortgage rates up, the buy-to-let landscape has left some landlords apprehensive about what direction to take their properties in, or if they should continue renting them out at all.
Profits
Uswitch.com BTL mortgages expert, Kellie Steed (pictured), says while it can feel like selling up is the only option, there are other ways landlords can keep profits afloat during the cost-of-living crisis.
“Switching to a letting management company offers some attractive advantages and gives landlords the scope to hold onto their investment,” she explains.
“Property managers have a strong knowledge of the market’s changing regulations and can also take on much of the responsibility of owning investment property – lettings, repairs, rental disputes and complaints can all be tackled by an agency.”
Many offer increasingly attractive packages for landlords in return for 10-20% of profits, says Steed.
“Remortgaging a property can also save landlords money, as any equity held in the property will give them access to cheaper rates,” she adds.
“While a lower interest rate could offer less expensive loan repayments, releasing equity on a property can boost your finances and give you, and your property, more support in the form of a cash sum.”
Read more: Agencies must help landlords navigate looming reforms.
View Full Article: EXTRA red tape, scams and repairs drive more landlords to use agencies
Daily Telegraph wants to speak to landlords about the Renters Reform Bill
Are you a landlord who is worried about the wide range of reforms expected in the Renters’ Reform Bill? Then, Alexa Phillips the personal finance reporter for the Telegraph would like to speak with you.
Alexa would like to speak to Property118 readers about:
- What do you think about the proposals in the bill
View Full Article: Daily Telegraph wants to speak to landlords about the Renters Reform Bill
Conservative MPs condemn government’s ‘war on landlords’
Tory MPs fear the soon-to-be-published Renters’ Reform Bill will force more landlords to sell up.
According to the Telegraph, there are growing concerns amongst Conservative MPs that the government has gone too far with its war on landlords.
View Full Article: Conservative MPs condemn government’s ‘war on landlords’
Categories
- Landlords (19)
- Real Estate (9)
- Renewables & Green Issues (1)
- Rental Property Investment (1)
- Tenants (21)
- Uncategorized (11,841)
Archives
- November 2024 (32)
- October 2024 (82)
- September 2024 (69)
- August 2024 (55)
- July 2024 (64)
- June 2024 (54)
- May 2024 (73)
- April 2024 (59)
- March 2024 (49)
- February 2024 (57)
- January 2024 (58)
- December 2023 (56)
- November 2023 (59)
- October 2023 (67)
- September 2023 (136)
- August 2023 (131)
- July 2023 (129)
- June 2023 (128)
- May 2023 (140)
- April 2023 (121)
- March 2023 (168)
- February 2023 (155)
- January 2023 (152)
- December 2022 (136)
- November 2022 (158)
- October 2022 (146)
- September 2022 (148)
- August 2022 (169)
- July 2022 (124)
- June 2022 (124)
- May 2022 (130)
- April 2022 (116)
- March 2022 (155)
- February 2022 (124)
- January 2022 (120)
- December 2021 (117)
- November 2021 (139)
- October 2021 (130)
- September 2021 (138)
- August 2021 (110)
- July 2021 (110)
- June 2021 (60)
- May 2021 (127)
- April 2021 (122)
- March 2021 (156)
- February 2021 (154)
- January 2021 (133)
- December 2020 (126)
- November 2020 (159)
- October 2020 (169)
- September 2020 (181)
- August 2020 (147)
- July 2020 (172)
- June 2020 (158)
- May 2020 (177)
- April 2020 (188)
- March 2020 (234)
- February 2020 (212)
- January 2020 (164)
- December 2019 (107)
- November 2019 (131)
- October 2019 (145)
- September 2019 (123)
- August 2019 (112)
- July 2019 (93)
- June 2019 (82)
- May 2019 (94)
- April 2019 (88)
- March 2019 (78)
- February 2019 (77)
- January 2019 (71)
- December 2018 (37)
- November 2018 (85)
- October 2018 (108)
- September 2018 (110)
- August 2018 (135)
- July 2018 (140)
- June 2018 (118)
- May 2018 (113)
- April 2018 (64)
- March 2018 (96)
- February 2018 (82)
- January 2018 (92)
- December 2017 (62)
- November 2017 (100)
- October 2017 (105)
- September 2017 (97)
- August 2017 (101)
- July 2017 (104)
- June 2017 (155)
- May 2017 (135)
- April 2017 (113)
- March 2017 (138)
- February 2017 (150)
- January 2017 (127)
- December 2016 (90)
- November 2016 (135)
- October 2016 (149)
- September 2016 (135)
- August 2016 (48)
- July 2016 (52)
- June 2016 (54)
- May 2016 (52)
- April 2016 (24)
- October 2014 (8)
- April 2012 (2)
- December 2011 (2)
- November 2011 (10)
- October 2011 (9)
- September 2011 (9)
- August 2011 (3)
Calendar
Recent Posts
- Landlords defy expectations of an ‘exodus’
- Bought a property at auction without details of existing tenant?
- Buying a property at auction with a sitting tenant?
- Government’s second homes policy doesn’t address the housing crisis
- Council inspects 500 PRS homes – and finds 2,000 issues