Does a Periodic Tenancy mean a new tenancy every month?
Periodic Tenancy:
Under English law, once a fixed period tenancy comes to an end it is automatically replaced with a periodic one, based on the rent payment period (commonly monthly), unless the original tenancy is terminated. With an Assured Shorthold Tenancy (AST) termination would be if the tenant leaves at the end of the term, or is served a 2 months’ notice by the landlord effective at the end of the term.
The periodic tenancy rolls on indefinitely if the parties wish it to, though interestingly, a determination in a test case (Superstrike Ltd v Marino Rodrigues 2013)1, contrary to what many in the industry believed at the time, a statutory periodic tenancy is a new and distinct tenancy, not a continuation of the tenant’s previous status.
On this basis a tenant sought to argue that a periodic tenancy is a new tenancy EVERY month. In Walcott v Jones & Jones November 2017, a county court appeal, the tenant argued that a tenancy which had started prior to the introduction of new rules (1st October 2015) the landlord had not complied with them before serving his s21 notice, and therefore the notice was invalid.
Tenancies commencing before the change date and up to 1st October next year (2018) do not have to comply with these new rules brought in under the Deregulation Act 2015 (s21A and s21B of Housing Act 1988) – meaning the landlord must provide the tenant with a gas safety certificate (if applicable), an EPC and the DCLG “How to Rent Guide” before a valid s21 notice can be served.
Clearly, if the plaintiffs could establish that the tenancy renewed each time then it could be argued the landlord did not comply, and that was the decision of the county court.
However, according to a note on the case on Giles Peaker’s Nearly Legal Blog, Ms W being the landlord of the Joneses, it was accepted for the purposes of the appeal that the new rules only apply to a tenancy that commenced on or after 1 October 2015 and until October 2018, including any “renewal tenancies”. The plaintiffs’ argument went that as the grant of tenancy was a monthly period from the start, (there was no written agreement), each month represented a new grant.
The appeal judge, Judge Hand QC, held that the grant of a periodic tenancy meant that if notice was not given in accordance with the agreement the tenancy would continue after the original term. Whether this was considered as an extension of the original term or a ‘deemed re-grant’ did not matter, as for the purposes of Housing Act 1988 (as amended), neither amounted to a ‘grant’ of a tenancy. Parliament did not intend a ‘grant’ in such circumstances. The county court judge had erred in law and the appeal was allowed.
A similar point arose recently in Leeds City Council v Broadley 2016 2 concerning council tax liability, where it was acknowledged that a periodic tenancy was a singular tenancy, as per the Law of Property Act 1925. In that case the court of appeal held that a tenancy grant for a year or six months, and thereafter a month to month periodic tenancy, was indeed a single tenancy.
The conclusion to all this is that a periodic tenancy it does not result in a new tenancy each period – it is in fact a single ongoing tenancy, from period to period. But, as per Superstrike, a statutory periodic tenancy that arises at the end of an AST fixed term, is a new tenancy, not a ‘renewal’ tenancy.
Superstrike Ltd v Marino Rodrigues 2013
Leeds City Council v Broadley 2016
©1999 – Present | Parkmatic Publications Ltd. All rights reserved | LandlordZONE® – Does a Periodic Tenancy mean a new tenancy every month? | LandlordZONE.
View Full Article: Does a Periodic Tenancy mean a new tenancy every month?
Post comment
Categories
- Landlords (19)
- Real Estate (9)
- Renewables & Green Issues (1)
- Rental Property Investment (1)
- Tenants (21)
- Uncategorized (11,918)
Archives
- December 2024 (45)
- November 2024 (64)
- October 2024 (82)
- September 2024 (69)
- August 2024 (55)
- July 2024 (64)
- June 2024 (54)
- May 2024 (73)
- April 2024 (59)
- March 2024 (49)
- February 2024 (57)
- January 2024 (58)
- December 2023 (56)
- November 2023 (59)
- October 2023 (67)
- September 2023 (136)
- August 2023 (131)
- July 2023 (129)
- June 2023 (128)
- May 2023 (140)
- April 2023 (121)
- March 2023 (168)
- February 2023 (155)
- January 2023 (152)
- December 2022 (136)
- November 2022 (158)
- October 2022 (146)
- September 2022 (148)
- August 2022 (169)
- July 2022 (124)
- June 2022 (124)
- May 2022 (130)
- April 2022 (116)
- March 2022 (155)
- February 2022 (124)
- January 2022 (120)
- December 2021 (117)
- November 2021 (139)
- October 2021 (130)
- September 2021 (138)
- August 2021 (110)
- July 2021 (110)
- June 2021 (60)
- May 2021 (127)
- April 2021 (122)
- March 2021 (156)
- February 2021 (154)
- January 2021 (133)
- December 2020 (126)
- November 2020 (159)
- October 2020 (169)
- September 2020 (181)
- August 2020 (147)
- July 2020 (172)
- June 2020 (158)
- May 2020 (177)
- April 2020 (188)
- March 2020 (234)
- February 2020 (212)
- January 2020 (164)
- December 2019 (107)
- November 2019 (131)
- October 2019 (145)
- September 2019 (123)
- August 2019 (112)
- July 2019 (93)
- June 2019 (82)
- May 2019 (94)
- April 2019 (88)
- March 2019 (78)
- February 2019 (77)
- January 2019 (71)
- December 2018 (37)
- November 2018 (85)
- October 2018 (108)
- September 2018 (110)
- August 2018 (135)
- July 2018 (140)
- June 2018 (118)
- May 2018 (113)
- April 2018 (64)
- March 2018 (96)
- February 2018 (82)
- January 2018 (92)
- December 2017 (62)
- November 2017 (100)
- October 2017 (105)
- September 2017 (97)
- August 2017 (101)
- July 2017 (104)
- June 2017 (155)
- May 2017 (135)
- April 2017 (113)
- March 2017 (138)
- February 2017 (150)
- January 2017 (127)
- December 2016 (90)
- November 2016 (135)
- October 2016 (149)
- September 2016 (135)
- August 2016 (48)
- July 2016 (52)
- June 2016 (54)
- May 2016 (52)
- April 2016 (24)
- October 2014 (8)
- April 2012 (2)
- December 2011 (2)
- November 2011 (10)
- October 2011 (9)
- September 2011 (9)
- August 2011 (3)
Calendar
Recent Posts
- Why choose The Home Insurer for landlord insurance?
- Landlords could pay tenants up to two years’ rent for failing Decent Homes Standard as PBSA is exempt
- Landlords’ Rights Bill: Let’s tell the government what we want
- 2025 will be crucial for leasehold reform as secondary legislation takes shape
- Reeves inflationary budget puts mockers on Bank Base Rate reduction